Jake Gyllenhaal takes on the role of Rusty Sabich, a prosecutor accused of murdering his female colleague, in the new Apple TV+ adaptation of Scott Turow s novel "Presumed Innocent." This role was originally played by Harrison Ford in the 1990 film adaptation.
The new adaptation emphasizes the psychological aspects and family drama over the original's well-made mystery. This shift in focus detracts from the courtroom credibility that was a hallmark of Turow s novel.
The novel's first-person narrative, which provided detailed analyses of Sabich s professional and personal life, is less prominent in the series. This change affects the grounding of the courtroom and prosecutor's office milieus and motivations.
David E. Kelley, known for his work on legal dramas, created the series. He restored and added plot points, some of which alter the original mystery s dynamics. Kelley's penchant for melodrama and sensationalism is evident throughout the series.
The series increases the frequency and intensity of flashback sex scenes between Sabich and the victim, Carolyn Polhemus, while reducing the focus on her competence and ambition, which were crucial in the original plot.
Kelley s adaptation includes courtroom scenes and decisions that violate sensible legal procedures, deviating significantly from more sober legal dramas. These inaccuracies contribute to the overall melodramatic tone of the series.
Jake Gyllenhaal's portrayal of Sabich is more emotional and erratic compared to Ford s reserved performance. Ruth Negga and Peter Sarsgaard also struggle with their roles due to the way the characters are written.
The adaptation tries to position itself as an allegory for cancel culture, with Sabich's life being upended by an accusation and his desperation shifting towards proving his moral integrity.